Finding Mr. Christmas will be back for a second go-round. Hallmark Media has renewed the reality competition series, created by Jonathan Bennett and Ben Roy, for a second season. It’s set to premiere on Hallmark+ in 2025.
“Bringing this show to life was such a dream come true,” said Bennett. “There’re definitely more stories to be told in season two and so much more fun to be had. We’re really just scratching the surface here”.
Bennett serves as host with Melissa Peterman as lead judge.
On Finding Mr. Christmas, ten aspiring actors compete in a variety of festive, entertaining challenges, with a Hallmark twist: the winner is crowned Mr. Christmas and given the opportunity to become Hallmark’s next leading man, with a starring role in a Countdown to Christmas movie. Season one’s winner, Ezra Moreland, made his movie debut, opposite Jessica Lowndes, in the new Hallmark Original movie, Happy Howlidays. The film aired on Hallmark Channel last weekend and is available to stream on Hallmark +.
“My hope for season one was that we would create something that would stand out in the reality TV landscape – a show that is competitive yet genuinely heartwarming and uplifting,” said Roy. “I am so proud of what our incredible cast and crew have achieved. The positive response from fans has been incredible. We can’t wait for the challenge to make season two even more heartfelt, more entertaining, and somehow… even more handsome.”
Added David Sefanou, Head of Unscripted Programming, Hallmark Media: “It’s nearly impossible to create a piece of entertainment that truly breaks through in this overcrowded market, let alone to make one that wears its heart on its sleeve while being deeply entertaining. Finding Mr. Christmas is that show, and we can’t wait to do it again”
Lisa Hamilton Daly, Executive Vice President of Programming, Hallmark Media, said “We are thrilled at the success of the first season and are proud to have created a reality competition series with heart at its core.”
Finding Mr. Christmas is produced by Hallmark Media and Super Delicious. The series is co-created by Jonathan Bennett and Ben Roy. Executive producers are Cara Tapper, Adam Cohen, Joanna Vernetti, Bennett, Roy and Trish Gold.